Conflict & Peace
Papua: Quick to Build, Slow to Listen
In early February 2026, the media was full of news from Wanam, Merauke. The logistics port of the National Strategic Project there was already 93 percent complete. It was scheduled to begin operating in March.
Fast. Neat. Measurable.
News like that is pleasant to read aloud. There is a port, there are fuel tanks, there are warehouses. The President himself had come to inspect Wanam back in November 2024. The state looks like it is working.
But there are other numbers that are rarely read aloud.
The Papuan Council of Churches recorded some 107 thousand people displaced as of April 2026. Komnas HAM, the National Human Rights Commission, recorded 42 violent incidents with 59 deaths between January and June. Most of them civilians.
The first number is announced. The second is merely recorded.
I am not rejecting development. What I want to say is simple. In Papua, the state is very quick to count concrete, but slow to count people.
Let us start with security.
An investigation by Project Multatuli, as cited by Human Rights Monitor, estimates that there are 74,297 soldiers in 31 regencies across the Land of Papua. Last January, LBH Papua recorded three new battalions being formed in Biak Numfor, Supiori, and Waropen. The reason is always the same. Safeguarding sovereignty. Protecting citizens.
Which citizens?
Last April, in Kembru, Puncak Regency, 12 civilians were killed in a military operation. There were women. There were children. Komnas HAM said there were strong indications that the perpetrators were soldiers.
Violence by armed groups exists too. Ten gold panners were killed in Yahukimo in May. That is a crime. The perpetrators must be brought to trial.
But the state must not respond in the same way. If people in the villages can no longer tell who is protecting them and who is threatening them, the state has already lost. No matter how many posts it builds.
This pattern is not new. Conflict in Papua has claimed thousands of lives and displaced thousands of people since the 1960s. The names of the operations change. The task forces change. The way of seeing stays the same. Papua is seen first as a security problem, and only later as a human one.
Then there is the matter of the displaced.
Displacement in Papua does not happen once. It recurs. Those who accompany the displaced say many of them have lived in a state of emergency for more than three years. An emergency that lasts too long eventually comes to be seen as normal. In Intan Jaya last January, hundreds of residents and students took to the streets demanding schools, health services, and the return of the displaced. Komnas HAM even used a heavy phrase: the loss of a Papuan generation.
If that many displaced people were in Klaten or Sleman, I suspect the cabinet would hold an emergency meeting that very night.
In Papua, all of this is simply called "the security situation".
Back to Wanam.
The Merauke food estate is planned to clear some 2.29 million hectares of forest and land. That is more than thirty times the size of Jakarta. Some residents support it because they hope for jobs. That is a reasonable hope. People who live in hardship have the right to hope.
But Merauke has a memory. There was MIFEE under SBY, and that project failed. Dwi Andreas Santosa of IPB has warned that many food estates fail because they do not meet four conditions: land suitability, technology, infrastructure, and socio-economic conditions. The Malind Anim indigenous people say their customary land was mapped unilaterally and their forests flattened without consent. When the indigenous community protested, Human Rights Watch judged the dispersal of their protest unlawful.
"The land is Mother," says Marlince Siep, a Papuan indigenous women's activist. From it comes food; in it the ancestors are buried. If that land is taken without permission, what is lost is more than a garden.
At this point I am reminded again of the Javanese political culture I once wrote about.
Jakarta likes to ngemong: to nurture, to give. This year's Special Autonomy (Otsus) fund is Rp12.69 trillion. The Land of Papua now has six provinces. There is also an Executive Committee for the Acceleration of Special Autonomy Development, sworn in by the President. From the outside, it all looks like kindness.
But those being nurtured are rarely asked what they want.
When the House of Representatives (DPR) passed three new provinces in June 2022, the Chair of the Papuan People's Assembly (MRP), Timotius Murib, said the division was not what Indigenous Papuans wanted. The MRP was not asked for its consent either.
The Governor of South Papua, Apolo Safanpo, has himself complained of overlapping regulations. Authority over forestry and mining is already set out in the Special Autonomy Law, yet in practice it still refers to central regulations. The administrative centres of the new provinces are not expected to be completed until 2028.
The money is sent. Control stays in Jakarta.
There is a saying, mikul dhuwur mendhem jero: hold up the good high, bury the bad deep. In Papua, the saying seems to work in only one direction. The centre wants to be held high as the giver. What gets buried is the voice of the Papuan people.
In wayang shadow puppetry, the dalang sits behind the kelir, the screen. The audience sees shadows moving, but the hand that moves them is not visible. Papua is often treated like that screen. Beautiful images are projected onto it. A port. New rice fields. A governor's office. Papuans themselves are rarely given the chance to hold the puppets.
Then the heaviest matter of all. Impunity.
Frits Ramandey, head of the Papua office of Komnas HAM, has admitted that his institution struggles to investigate alleged violations involving members of the TNI, the Indonesian military. The 2014 Paniai case is an example. Four people were killed. Eight years later, only one defendant was tried, and he was acquitted.
As long as this continues, Papuans will read the same message. Their lives are valued more cheaply.
I do not want to allege an evil plan behind all this. Perhaps it is only an old habit. The habit of speaking to Papua, not with Papua.
But a habit left in place for years eventually becomes a system.
Let us ask honestly. Have Papuans ever been asked how they want to be developed? Have they ever had a say in how many soldiers come to their villages? Were their voices ever counted when the map of National Strategic Projects was drawn?
So what needs to be criticised today? In my view, the way of seeing.
Reduce the troops, open dialogue. Return the displaced with written guarantees of security. Halt the Merauke National Strategic Project until the indigenous communities truly consent. Try human rights violators, from whichever side, in courts the public can see.
In January 2024, Prabowo once told his volunteers: menang tanpo ngasorake. Win without humiliating. If the President truly believes in that philosophy, Papua is the place to prove it.
The port at Wanam has been 93 percent complete since January.
Listening to Papua, to this day, has still not begun.
Readers’ Responses