Culture & Anthropology
Javanese Political Culture: Borrowed Hands
The embrace took place at Merdeka Palace on Thursday, 12 November 2026.
President Prabowo Subianto embraced Gibran Rakabuming Raka in front of the cameras, moments after accepting his deputy's resignation. He praised Gibran's service. He promised to keep supporting him.
In Solo, Joko Widodo struck the same note. He would continue to support Prabowo's government. Political office, he said, is only temporary.
Warm. Harmonious. Polite.
But let us go back two days. On Tuesday, 10 November, Gibran told reporters that the President had advised him to keep fighting in court. Less than a day later, a denial arrived. Not from the President's own mouth, but from the Head of the Government Communication Agency, Syahganda Nainggolan: the President could not possibly have encouraged further legal resistance.
The President did not deny it. The President embraced. Someone else did the denying.
This is the Javanese style of politics. Affectionate in front. Striking from behind. And the one who strikes is always someone else's hand.
The Javanese have a name for it: nabok nyilih tangan. To strike with a borrowed hand.
Why do two figures who clearly disagree never quarrel in public? The answer lies in Javanese ethics itself. There, open confrontation is a disgrace. It is considered coarse, ill-mannered, not njawani, not properly Javanese.
Franz Magnis-Suseno, in his study of Javanese ethics, names two basic principles: rukun and hormat. Rukun means that harmony must always be preserved. Hormat means that everyone must always show respect in speech and conduct. The best-known expression of rukun is the avoidance of open conflict.
But conflict does not disappear simply because it is forbidden to appear. It moves elsewhere. From the stage to behind the curtain. From the mouth to someone else's hand. From the lit room to the dark one.
And so a complete toolkit was born. There is ewuh pakewuh, the reluctance to speak frankly. There is menang tanpa ngasorake, winning without humiliating the opponent. There is mikul dhuwur mendhem jero, holding up a person's merits and burying their faults deep. And there is nabok nyilih tangan, for the moment when an opponent really must be brought down.
All these tools share one purpose: the face must stay clean. The smile must be kept. Let someone else's hands get dirty.
Even the language is made gentle. Criticism is not delivered directly, but through pasemon, an allusion understood only by its target. Refusal is not spoken with the word "no", but with "not yet" or "we'll see". Anger is hidden behind the phrase aku rapopo, I'm fine.
Jokowi himself often used Javanese idioms to answer criticism. Aku rapopo entered the national political vocabulary. Ojo kesusu, don't rush, became a way of postponing without refusing. The words are soft. The message gets through. No one can point a finger.
This political culture was born in the world of the palace and the priyayi aristocracy. There, the king is never wrong and never angry in public. The king's wrath is conveyed through courtiers, through the chief minister, through envoys. The king himself remains seated calmly on his throne.
The history of this republic records the same pattern. In 1966, Soeharto never openly attacked Soekarno. He still called him Bung Karno and still showed him respect. Yet Soekarno's power was stripped away bit by bit, through a letter of instruction, through sessions of the Provisional People's Consultative Assembly, through other hands. Soekarno fell without ever being confronted face to face.
Soeharto then ruled for three decades in a similar way. Opponents were rarely faced directly. They were removed through distant postings, through investigations, through riots whose masterminds were never made clear.
Now look at the past few weeks.
On 30 October, the Supreme Court annulled the certificate recognising Gibran's foreign high school diploma as equivalent. In early November, the National Police Criminal Investigation Agency named three senior police generals as suspects in the illegal wiretapping of the President. One of them was Listyo Sigit Prabowo, National Police Chief under Jokowi. The Palace said the act pointed towards treason, while Coordinating Minister Yusril Ihza Mahendra stated there was as yet no indication of treason. All suspects remain entitled to the presumption of innocence.
Before that, three cadres of the PSI, the party Jokowi now belongs to, resigned from the cabinet. Jokowi's legacy projects were sorted through one by one. Last July, Prabowo and Gibran sat apart at a cabinet meeting, and the Palace hurried to deny any rift.
No one said, "We are at odds." No one said, "We are parting ways." The analyst Adi Prayitno spoke only of a psychological distance, no longer as warm as before.
That distance was never announced. It could only be read from shifting chairs, departing cadres, and spokespeople issuing denials.
I am not accusing anyone of orchestrating all this. The law may indeed be taking its course. But the pattern is too familiar to ignore. Every blow comes from the hand of an institution. Every embrace comes from the hand of a leader.
That is why Jakarta politics is often hard to read. What is said is not what is meant. The one who smiles is not necessarily a friend. The one who embraces does not necessarily support. One has to read the signs: who sits where, who is not invited, who is suddenly investigated.
Politics becomes like wayang, the shadow puppet play. The audience watches the characters fight on the screen. But the one moving them all is the dalang, the puppeteer, sitting calmly behind the screen. The clever spectator does not watch the puppets. He watches the puppeteer's hands.
Benedict Anderson, in The Idea of Power in Javanese Culture, explains its deepest roots. In the Javanese view, true power is calm. It does not need to shout. It does not need to be angry. It does not need to strike for itself. A ruler who loses his composure is in fact showing that his power has begun to leak away.
Therefore, anger in public is defeat. Attacking an opponent openly means admitting that one feels threatened. The halus, the refined, wins. The kasar, the coarse, loses, even before the fight begins.
Wayang teaches the same lesson. Arjuna is portrayed as refined: he speaks softly, his face is lowered, his movements are calm. The giants are portrayed as coarse: they shout, glare, and rage. The audience knows who will win.
So the Javanese political contest is a contest of keeping face. Whoever loses their smile first is the loser. Whoever stays calmest is the most powerful.
In this logic, an embrace is not merely a sign of peace. An embrace can be a statement. It shows the public who is calmest, most generous, most njawani. It also closes off any room for the other side to complain. How can someone claim to have been struck by the person who has just embraced him?
The embrace at Merdeka Palace may have been sincere. Perhaps not. In Javanese politics, no one can be sure of it from the face.
All that can be seen are the hands. And those hands are, almost always, borrowed hands.
Readers’ Responses