All notes

Conflict & Peace

Relocating Javan Rhinos, Forgetting Papuan People

On Thursday, 12 November 2026, at a press briefing on the sidelines of the COP31 climate conference in Antalya, Turkey, Hashim Djojohadikusumo voiced his unease. The President's Special Envoy for Climate and Energy was worried about the fate of the Javan rhino in Ujung Kulon National Park. Mount Anak Krakatau, he said, could trigger a tsunami, and if that happened, our Javan rhinos could go extinct. For that reason the government plans to move some of the rhinos to Alas Purwo National Park in Banyuwangi. The funding will be sought from investors through a conservation financing scheme.

I read that news with mixed feelings. Hashim's concern makes sense. Only about 87 to 100 Javan rhinos remain, and all of them live in one place. The idea of finding a second habitat is nothing new either; experts have been discussing it since the 1980s. Nor is Hashim a newcomer to wildlife matters. Through the Arsari Djojohadikusumo Foundation, he built a Sumatran tiger rehabilitation centre in Dharmasraya and an orangutan sanctuary in East Kalimantan.

But precisely because his concern is so real, I cannot stop asking. If a tsunami that has not yet happened can move a presidential envoy to speak at a world forum, why does the tsunami that has long been striking people in Papua not unsettle him in the same way?

That tsunami is called armed conflict.

Last July, Deputy Minister of Human Rights Mugiyanto cited the figure that had reached his ministry: some 122 thousand people displaced by the prolonged armed conflict in Papua. One hundred and twenty-two thousand human beings, while the Javan rhinos that trouble Hashim number fewer than a hundred. Komnas HAM recorded that in the first half of 2026 there were 42 incidents of violence and armed conflict, with 59 people killed and 50 others injured. Last September, the commission described the situation in Papua as "increasingly in crisis".

Those numbers have faces. On World Refugee Day last June, Leri Gwijangge reminded us that the people of Nduga have been displaced since 2 December 2018. It is now almost eight years. His parents, his relatives and the children of his village still live as refugees in Wamena and Kwiyawagi. According to him, the government is still busy with short-term aid, while their education, health care and return to their villages have yet to be addressed. The Jakarta Post noted that most Papuan refugees are women and children.

Javan rhinos threatened by a tsunami are to be given a new home. The children of Nduga, who have been without a home for almost eight years, have still not been brought back.

The comparison grows even more bitter when we recall November last year. To move a single male rhino named Musofa, even though the move was only within the Ujung Kulon area itself, the state deployed combat vehicles of the Marine Corps. When Musofa died of illness, the Ministry of Forestry held a press conference to explain the chronology. I do not take issue with that. One rhino is indeed precious. But when was the last time we saw the state hold a press conference to explain the death of a child in a Papuan refugee camp?

This is where my criticism lies, for Hashim and for his elder brother, President Prabowo Subianto.

What I have noticed is that whenever the two of them speak about Papua, what is heard more often is its land, not its people. In December 2024, Hashim rejected accusations of deforestation in the food estate project in South Papua by saying that 60 percent of the land was empty, treeless, mostly grassland. A year later, on 16 December 2025, Prabowo asked regional heads across Papua to plant Papuan land with oil palm to produce fuel. Papua is spoken of as land, as an energy reserve, as a food barn. Very rarely as home to more than a hundred thousand people who have now been driven from their villages.

I am not saying the President is incapable of empathy. He is capable, and he has shown it. On the night of the turn of the year into 2026, Prabowo chose to spend the night with flash-flood refugees in Batu Hula, South Tapanuli. He ate with them, hugged the children, watched a film together, and then said, "Your President will not abandon you, brothers and sisters." That gesture deserves appreciation.

But in the same holiday season, according to church circles and civil society in Papua, many Indigenous Papuans celebrated Christmas and the New Year not in their home villages, but in the middle of the forest, in refugee camps. As far as I could follow from the news, no president came to hug their children. No words like "Your President will not abandon you" were heard as far as Nduga, Intan Jaya or Puncak.

Two months later, Prabowo offered himself as a mediator in the tensions between the United States, Israel and Iran, even ready to fly to Tehran if both sides agreed to dialogue. He can imagine himself as a peacemaker in the Middle East, yet seems to forget the dialogue he once promised for Papua.

In the first presidential debate, on 12 December 2023, Prabowo said that human rights issues in Papua "must be our priority". He promised to protect the people of Papua and guarantee the upholding of human rights, even stating that he agreed "we must uphold justice, we must have dialogue." Almost three years later, that promise has not been kept. Dialogue has still not been opened despite constant pressure from churches and civil society. What has increased instead are battalions and refugees.

The Javanese know tepa selira, the ability to measure the feelings of others by one's own feelings. Tepa selira does not choose. It does not stop in Tapanuli and turn back before reaching Wamena. Nor can it be more sensitive to rhinos than to human children.

I do not object to the Javan rhino being saved. Let the experts decide whether Alas Purwo is truly the right place, since a number of observers have already questioned its scientific basis. What I question is the order of concern. The Ministry of Human Rights has indeed stated that it is coordinating with the TNI and Polri to deal with the refugees. But last October, the think tank Merah Pusaka Stratejik Indonesia still had to propose that the state form a special agency for Papua's internally displaced people, because handling was judged to be still sectoral. When the state hurries to find investors to relocate wildlife, while human refugees are cared for in a patchwork way, we have every reason to ask: who is actually considered worthy of being saved?

Papuan refugees are not asking for special treatment. They only want to go home. They want their children back in school, their sick able to get treatment, and their villages no longer a firing range. That request is far simpler than moving a one-horned rhino from the western tip to the eastern tip of the island of Java.

Hashim fears the Javan rhino will go extinct because of a tsunami. That fear is reasonable. But in Papua, the tsunami arrived years ago, and its waves have yet to recede. What has been swept away is not rhinos. What has been swept away are human beings, our fellow citizens, who to this day are still waiting for someone to come, not to relocate them, but to bring them home.

Readers’ Responses

Be the first to respond