All notes

Government & Autonomy

The Papuan People's Assembly: Angel and Devil

My book, MRP: Reformed or Dissolved?, was published in 2026 by Ikan Paus. In this essay, let me tell you why it came into being, what it seeks to answer, and why its central question matters to all of us in Tanah Papua, a land too often spoken about and too rarely listened to.

On its dedication page is a sentence that perhaps represents the whole book more honestly than any other: I believe the MRP is an angel and a devil. Not one or the other. Both at once.

That sentence is more than rhetoric. It grew out of four years inside the Papuan People's Assembly as a member, from 2012 to 2016, and the years that followed. As Regent of Dogiyai, I saw from the executive side how the institution's limitations became a real burden in the villages.

My fellow campaigners and I once 'fought one another in earnest and embraced one another in earnest'. Bonds like that never truly disappear. It is precisely because of them that I feel I owe it to everyone to write honestly: with no wish to praise, and no wish to attack.

One question has long refused to leave me in peace. Does the MRP genuinely protect Indigenous Papuans, or is it merely an expensive ornament? An institution that exists in law, but scarcely exists in politics.

That question burst into public view in March 2026. A senator from Tanah Papua openly called for the MRP to be dissolved, and its leadership responded in a tone that was, frankly, more emotional than substantive.

The controversy did not stop in Papua. It reached Jakarta, drew in the Ministry of Home Affairs, and became a subject of national debate. I watched it unfold with mixed feelings.

I was concerned, but I also believed that a debate so fierce was a sign of a healthy democracy, not a threat to it. For me, a good leader answers criticism with reflection, not defensiveness. A hard question opens a rare opportunity to speak more honestly about the MRP.

So I chose not merely to comment, but to analyse. Such depth, I believe, can only come from someone who has been inside the institution. That is how this book began.

I recognise that my position is unusual. I was once inside the MRP, but can now see it more clearly from the outside: a former member who understands its inner workings, and a former regional leader who bore the consequences of its limitations on the ground.

I brought a rigorous theoretical framework to bear on both experiences, so that the book would become neither an outpouring of disappointment nor a loyalist's defence.

This book was not written to please everyone. It was written to be honest. And in Papua, burdened for too long by rhetoric so far removed from reality, honesty is perhaps the most valuable contribution one can make.

Three voices have long echoed through the debate over the MRP's future. Some want to dissolve it, some to preserve it, and others to reform it. Each position holds part of the truth, and each has its blind spots.

The book seeks to bridge those positions, not in the spirit of a faction convinced it alone is right, but through comprehensive understanding. What does it contain? It traces the MRP back to its birth.

The institution was born of the 2001 Special Autonomy Law, a major compromise amid the wave of demands that followed Reformasi in 1998, when one hundred Papuan leaders met President Habibie and declared their wish to leave Indonesia.

Jakarta chose a middle path: granting recognition while withholding power. That is where the inborn flaw began. The MRP was presented as a body representing Indigenous Papuans culturally, yet was given only the authority to 'offer consideration', not binding powers.

It was given a mandate to protect, without the power to compel. It was like a guard given a uniform but never given the keys. Many who have held seats in the MRP came with sincere intentions and a commitment that is hard to doubt.

But good intentions can never make up for a flaw in the design. That, in essence, is what I seek to demonstrate. For two decades, the consequences have been felt. Customary land has changed hands by the hundreds of thousands of hectares.

The creation of new administrative regions has proceeded with scarcely any meaningful consent from the MRP. Its members were even arrested while discussing special autonomy. Their legal challenge to the Constitutional Court was rejected. And at the end of 2025, state institutions themselves acknowledged that the first phase of Special Autonomy had failed to achieve its aims. Through every crisis, one question recurred: where was the MRP?

Behind the figures there are always faces. I think of the displaced people from Nduga, Intan Jaya, Maybrat and a number of other regencies, moving from place to place, living in churches, in gardens, at the forest's edge; children who have stopped going to school; mothers giving birth far from any helping hand.

Statistics can be read calmly, but they are written in tears. Crises like these should be at the heart of the MRP's work. Yet it is precisely here that, too often, the MRP is absent.

To answer the question fairly, I do not stop at complaint. I compare the MRP with similar bodies and arrangements around the world, such as the Waitangi Tribunal in New Zealand and the state's duty to consult Indigenous peoples in Canada.

The comparison shows what gives Indigenous representation real teeth, and what reduces it to an ornament. From it I reach a difficult but necessary conclusion: representation without power is an illusion, not protection.

So what is the verdict: reform or dissolution? Here, I want to be as honest as I can. The answer is not mine to give. Nor is it the prerogative of any senator or MRP chair.

The decision rests with the Government of the Republic of Indonesia and all the people of Papua, especially Indigenous Papuans, who have the most direct stake in it. All I can do, and that is the purpose of this book, is help ensure that when the decision is made, it is made with full knowledge, not in a moment of anger.

The book therefore offers no black-and-white verdict. It offers a conditional judgement. The MRP deserves one final term in which to prove itself, subject to concrete conditions, enforceable deadlines and clear consequences if it fails. Neither blind praise nor a death sentence, but a fair chance.

I did not write this book for the sake of theory. Indigenous Papuans are not characters in an academic treatise. They are my brothers and sisters in the most real sense. I grew up in Tanah Papua, and I learned the meaning of community from the peoples whose interests this book seeks to defend.

Their land, their forests and their dignity deserve to be safeguarded not merely with ink on paper, but with protection felt in their own yards and at their own hearths.

To Papua's younger generation, I entrust one message through this book. Never stop asking questions. Do not accept any institution that claims to represent you without demanding proof that it truly works for you. And do not let anyone, myself included, claim a monopoly on interpreting your future.

I believe the MRP is an angel and a devil. This book is my attempt to look at both with open eyes, and to invite us all to weigh its future with cool heads and honest hearts.

For Papua has never lacked voices. What it has long awaited is for those voices to be truly heard, and for promises to be truly kept.

Book Details

Title: MRP: Reformed or Dissolved? (Policy Analysis, Constructive Criticism, and Choices for Papua's Future) · Author: Yakobus Dumupa · Publisher: Ikan Paus Lembata · 2026 · 15 × 23 cm · xvi + 400 pages

First published in odiyaiwuu.com

Readers’ Responses

Be the first to respond