All notes

Politics & Leadership

The Javanese Face in Indonesia’s Scandals of Power

The year 2026 has offered a political spectacle that leaves many people shaking their heads. A former president came to court as a witness in a case that began with a single diploma. In the dock sat two of his critics, Roy Suryo and Dr Tifa, who were arrested in June and lost their pretrial challenge. On 6 October, the Constitutional Court stated that it had found no document proving that Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka had completed senior high school, though the court also said it had no authority to remove him from office. Three weeks later, the Supreme Court ruled that the certificate recognising his high school diploma as equivalent was invalid. Then, on 3 November, the National Police Criminal Investigation Agency named suspects in the alleged illegal tapping of President Prabowo Subianto’s telephone. According to news reports, one of them is a former National Police chief. Everyone mentioned here is still a suspect or a defendant, and must be presumed innocent until a final verdict.

In coffee stalls, all these events are usually summed up in one short sentence: that is simply Javanese politics. Disgrace is covered up to protect the good name of the elders, children rise on the family name, and ears are quietly placed close to the king. The sentence sounds as if it explains everything. But does it?

The answer: yes, but only in part. We need to distinguish two things, the face and the hand. The face is the names, titles and etiquette used to make power look legitimate and proper. The hand is the actual deed: covering up wrongdoing, passing on office, or spying on rivals. The face of our politics borrows a great deal from Java. Its hand does not necessarily. The three scandals above show both at once.

A Habit of Power, Not an Ethnicity

To avoid misunderstanding, the word Javanese here does not refer to the Javanese as an ethnic group. It refers to habits of power that grew in the royal courts, among the priyayi, the bureaucratic gentry, and the pangreh praja, the native officials of the Dutch era. Farmers in Gunungkidul or labourers in Surabaya are not part of it. They are, in fact, the ones who most often bear its consequences. The fiercest criticism of these habits has also come from the Javanese themselves, from Kartini to Pramoedya Ananta Toer.

These habits are easily recognised by anyone who has dealt with a government office. Officials smile warmly while pushing rivals aside. Subordinates always nod, yet the work never gets done. Kickbacks are called tokens of respect, office is treated as a source of income, and superiors’ mistakes are buried to protect their good name. These habits do not stay on the island of Java. They are carried by anyone who learns them, to whatever office they serve in, from Aceh to Papua.

It is from this world that the state borrowed its face. The process can be called Javanisation. Its materials come from anywhere, whether from the Dutch, the Japanese, Europe or the army barracks, and are then given Javanese names so that they sound familiar and noble. On 31 May 1945, Soepomo described the state he envisioned as a union of kawulo and gusti, servant and master, although the idea came from European and Japanese theory. The corps of officials created by the Dutch was later named pamong, meaning guardian. Gotong royong, which originally meant neighbours helping one another, was used in 2024 by the Speaker of the People’s Consultative Assembly to describe a state without opposition. Through names like these, officials are imagined as priyayi and the people as their servants. One nurtures and gives orders; the other simply obeys.

A Javanese Face, but Not Necessarily a Javanese Hand

The Javanese face entered the state not through blood but through opportunity. The Javanese are the largest group. The presidency was long held by figures close to the priyayi world. The priyayi were schooled first, and the Republic inherited a bureaucracy and an army that had grown up in Java. After that, civil service academies, ideological training and the civil servants’ corps kept spreading it across the country. We see its traces every day: the motto Tut Wuri Handayani, protocol rules on who must call on whom, and official language that calls officials protectors and the people those who are protected.

Even so, there is a line that must be kept. That Javanese names and etiquette are present in the state can be proven. But kickbacks, the buying and selling of office, violence and impunity have not been proven to come from Javanese custom. All of these also happen outside Java, committed by officials of every ethnic group. Their causes are more easily found in the colonial legacy, military power and money. In other words, the Javanese face did not create the damage. It makes the damage look normal, even virtuous. It is through this lens that the three scandals can be read.

Jokowi’s Diploma: Burying Disgrace for the Sake of a Good Name

Whether the diploma is genuine is for the courts to decide. What deserves attention is how power has responded to the question. For years, public questions about a single document were never settled through an open examination acceptable to all sides. In the end, it was the people asking the questions who were taken to the police. The good name of the elder was protected first, while citizens’ questions were treated as a nuisance. Yet in a republic, asking about an official’s qualifications is a citizen’s right, not disrespect towards one’s elders.

Here the face of mikul dhuwur mendhem jero appears: to hold one’s parents’ honour high and bury their faults deep. Within a family, this counsel is a noble teaching of filial devotion. The problem arises when those in power use it. Soeharto called it a “guide for life” when he succeeded Sukarno. His relatives invoked it when his legal case was questioned in 2008. In July 2025, the phrase was heard again from the head of state’s podium, this time as a name for Indonesian democracy.

A similar face shows in other habits. In May 2023, ahead of the election of his successor, Jokowi declared that he had to cawe-cawe, a Javanese word that makes political interference sound like a household matter. At Lebaran 2025, several ministers paid a sowan visit to his home in Solo, and one of them called Jokowi “still my boss”. The polite word was used to name political loyalty.

Yet cases are not held back by proverbs. Not a single court ruling mentions mendhem jero. What holds them back is the strong position of the person to be examined and the speed with which the authorities move against critics. The proverb merely makes all this sound like good manners.

Gibran’s Diploma: A Family Stage

The Gibran case shows another face: dynasty. In March 2023 he received the title Kanjeng Pangeran Haryo from the Mangkunegaran Palace, and his younger brother became a party chairman within a matter of days. Palace titles and ceremonies gave this family a stage, as if they truly belonged at the top.

In fact, this furniture-trading family from Solo has no priyayi lineage, and the title was bestowed, not inherited. Nor did the vice presidency come from a family tree. It came from Constitutional Court Decision 90, which changed the age requirement for candidates, from the parties that nominated him, and from the institution that approved his file without verifying his educational qualifications. Later, the Constitutional Court judged that the document submitted proved only that he had studied abroad, not that he had graduated. Now the Supreme Court has annulled that certificate, while the Vice President’s side insists his office is unaffected.

At this point, the culture of harmony is at work again. The people are asked to nrima, to accept, and not to make a fuss, while the negligent institutions feel no need to explain anything. The call for a “polite democracy” heard so often lately goes hand in hand with an ever quieter opposition in parliament. Politeness becomes a one-way demand: the people are asked to be courteous, the powerful are not asked to answer. The face is indeed Javanese, but the hand is court rulings, party machinery and lax vetting of documents.

Prabowo’s Wiretapping: Ears Close to the King

The wiretapping scandal is the most tempting to read through the lens of the court. The history of the Javanese palace knows ears placed by the king, slanderous whispers around the throne, and the proverb nabok nyilih tangan, striking with a borrowed hand. The Secretary-General of PDI-P even called the case “hostage politics”, a term that fits that picture well.

Yet it is here that the Javanese face is thinnest. The case centres on official police tapping equipment allegedly used without procedure, targeting the president, politicians, journalists and businesspeople. This resembles intelligence work under the New Order, when political opponents were watched and pressured without an official trace. To explain it, we need not look to the palace. Weapons, intelligence, office and weak oversight of armed institutions are enough. The difference is that now the one being tapped is the president himself. It is a sign that unsupervised state instruments can turn and bite anyone.

Removing the Face, Holding the Hand to Account

So, are these three scandals Javanese-style politics? In terms of the face, partly yes. The language used to defend power around these cases is largely borrowed from the priyayi world: mendhem jero for good names, sowan for loyalty, palace titles for a family stage, and harmony to silence questions. In terms of the hand, not necessarily. Critics dragged to the police, rulings that favour the ruling family, and wiretapping by the authorities are institutional failures that also occur in countries that know nothing of krama speech. Javanisation does not explain why Indonesia is broken. It only explains why we accept the damage so easily.

This distinction matters because it determines the remedy. If everything is regarded as innate to an ethnic group, the people can only resign themselves and prejudice between regions grows thicker. If face and hand are separated, the task becomes clear. The face must be removed: the words and etiquette that make abuse look virtuous. The hand must be controlled through overseers who stand outside the institutions they oversee, courts brave enough to confront high officials, open vetting of candidates’ qualifications, and strict control over permission to tap. A state that speaks more politely but still protects its rulers has not changed at all.

There is a simple way to read our politics. Ask who calls himself a guardian, who must come to pay respects, what words are used to justify a seat, and whose mistakes are supposedly to be buried. The answers will show where the Javanese face is worn and whose hand works behind it. The good news is that Javanese tradition itself has counsel for rebuking rulers: ojo dumeh, do not abuse your position. Members of Sarekat Islam who in 1913 refused to squat before the priyayi also proved that people used to bowing can learn to stand. Habit is not destiny. A face put on by human decision can be removed by the decision of the people themselves.

Readers’ Responses

Be the first to respond