Politics & Leadership
Winners, Not Leaders
For more than two decades, this nation has chosen its leaders by direct vote: presidents since 2004, regional heads since 2005. We call it progress and take pride in presenting ourselves on the international stage as the world’s third-largest democracy. Let us set that pride aside for a moment and ask one honest question: what have we really produced with those hundreds of trillions of rupiah and thousands of ballot boxes?
The answer is bitter. We have produced winners. Not leaders.
The two words sound much alike, yet they are as far apart as heaven and earth. A winner is someone who secures the most votes on a particular day. A leader is someone capable of looking after the lives of hundreds of thousands of people for five full years. Our electoral system is carefully designed to select the first, and not designed at all to find the second.
No Test
Open the election law and the law governing regional elections. Look for a provision that tests whether a candidate can read the structure of an APBD, the regional budget, understand the logic of development planning, grasp spatial planning, or simply tell capital expenditure from personnel costs. You will not find one. There are only administrative requirements: at least a senior secondary school diploma, physical and mental fitness, no current prison sentence, and a stack of documents to submit.
That is all. To manage one to two trillion rupiah of public money a year in a regency, this country asks for no proof of ability whatsoever. A public transport driver is tested far more rigorously before being licensed to carry twelve passengers.
All we have are candidate debates. A few televised appearances, with questions that have often been leaked and answers memorised the night before. These debates are not tests of competence. They are stages for rhetoric, and rhetoric can be hired. Consultants sell it complete with scripts, gestures and even a choice of shirt colour.
So the people who appear before us are those most fluent in the language of prosperity, progress and dignity, without ever being able to explain how to achieve them. Those who truly understand their region often lose out on that stage. They answer with figures, and figures do not draw applause.
The Money Filter
This is where the real rot lies. Before facing the people, a candidate must first face the ticket counter.
Research by the Ministry of Home Affairs, repeatedly cited by the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) in various forums, puts the cost of standing for regent or mayor at around twenty to thirty billion rupiah. For governor, the figure exceeds one hundred billion. A KPK deputy chair has even said that such sums may not be enough to win. To secure victory, a candidate may need to spend fifty to seventy billion.
Do the arithmetic calmly. A regent’s basic salary and allowances over five years do not amount to one and a half billion rupiah. Mathematically, no sane person throws away thirty billion to gain one and a half billion. Unless they already know where to find another return on their investment.
And everyone in this republic knows what that source is.
Those sums act as a filter, screening bank balances rather than minds. A senior teacher who has served for thirty years and knows every village in the district will never get through. A doctor who knows exactly why the maternal mortality rate is high in the area will never get through. An engineer who understands why regency roads crumble every rainy season will not even be invited to speak. They do not have thirty billion, and they have no wealthy backer willing to put up the money.
Those who do get through are timber merchants, mining permit holders, major contractors and people with access to their pockets. The system is not failing. It is working exactly as designed.
Parties Have Stopped Cultivating Leaders
In any theory of politics, parties are factories for leaders. They recruit, educate, test and train their members, then send them into public life. In this country, that function died long ago, and we all pretend not to see the corpse.
Our parties today operate as ticket counters. Endorsements go to the names most likely to win and the thickest envelopes. A party member who has spent twenty years honing their skills at branch level is left to put up billboards. The law prohibits political dowries. That prohibition lives on paper and dies everywhere else. Almost no party has ever been sanctioned for accepting one.
With leadership development dead, parties take shortcuts. Celebrities are recruited because their faces are already familiar. Businesspeople are brought in because their money is already available. The children, wives, younger siblings and children-in-law of serving officials are put forward because the political machine is already warmed up. Dynasties flourish not because people love a particular family, but because only that family has the capital and bureaucratic networks.
Twenty years have passed. Our parties have failed to produce a generation of leaders forged through a process of development. All they have produced is a list of names they can sell.
Votes for Sale
There is a part of this criticism that is uncomfortable to voice, and precisely for that reason it must be voiced. Voters are complicit in their own undoing.
The ‘dawn attack’ is no secret any more: the last-minute distribution of inducements before polling. Envelopes of cash, sarongs, staple foods, transport money and promises of village projects have become a normal part of our five-year cycle. In many places, a candidate who arrives empty-handed is considered unserious and disrespectful to the hosts.
Every vote sold for two hundred thousand rupiah closes the door on the seller’s right to demand anything for the next five years. The transaction is completed in the polling booth. You have been paid. The account is settled. When the road is not repaired, medicines run out at the community health centre and teachers do not turn up for class, you have lost the moral grounds for anger.
I am not defending politicians. I am slapping all of us awake. A democracy in which votes can be bought will always produce leaders who feel they have purchased their office, rather than received it as a trust.
The Bill Comes Due
And so the circle is complete. A person whose abilities have never been tested, who owes sponsors tens of billions and who has never been trained by a party, finally takes a seat of power. The first months are not spent improving public services. They are spent recouping the investment and repaying favours.
Anyone can predict the pattern. Posts are sold to officials who can afford them. Procurement contracts are arranged to go to financial backers. Permits are issued in return for favours. The inspectorate stays silent because the regional head is its own superior. The DPRD, the regional legislative council, keeps quiet because it gets a share.
KPK data speak more loudly than any argument. Since 2004, more than two hundred regional heads have been caught up in corruption cases handled by the commission alone, not counting those dealt with by prosecutors and police. Even among those elected in the 2024 regional elections, known as Pilkada, some have already been arrested just nine months into their terms. Nine months. They had not even completed one full budget cycle.
We are accustomed to reading such stories as individual cases. One person made a mistake, another was greedy. That is a lazy reading. When hundreds of people from different parties, different ethnic groups and different islands repeat exactly the same acts, the problem is no longer the individuals but the machine that produces them.
Not a Longing for the New Order
This criticism will surely be met with an answer I can already foresee. If direct elections are bad, return the choice to the DPRD, or hand it over to a more controlled mechanism.
I reject that path. Moving elections to the DPRD merely moves the marketplace from the village to the council chamber. Where once one had to buy a hundred thousand citizens’ votes, now it would be enough to buy thirty councillors’ votes. Cheaper, quieter and far harder to scrutinise. And the biggest losers would remain the same: the people, stripped even of their right to have a say.
We must also honestly acknowledge that direct elections have given us things that were once impossible. Regional heads can now be removed through the ballot box without a coup. A number of figures with no political blue blood have risen through this system and governed well. Papua has such names too.
What is broken is not the people’s right to choose. What is broken is the cost we have allowed to spiral out of control and the selection process we have allowed to remain empty.
What Must Be Dismantled
Four things, none of them impossible.
First, a legally mandated fit-and-proper test for all candidates for regional head, with the results made public. The aim is not to disqualify candidates. It is to open voters’ eyes before they cast their ballots. If a candidate cannot read a budget document, let the people know beforehand.
Second, limits on campaign funding and full disclosure of its sources, backed by independent audits and the annulment of an offending candidate’s victory. As long as violations bring only a reprimand, they will continue to be treated as an operating cost.
Third, a substantial increase in state funding for parties, accompanied by an auditable obligation to develop their members and the withdrawal of the right to nominate candidates from parties proven to have accepted political dowries. As long as parties are left to fend for themselves, they will keep selling whatever they can.
Fourth, law enforcement bold enough to reach the financial backers, rather than stopping at the officials caught in the act. As long as the wealthy sponsors remain safe, this factory will keep turning out the same product from the same raw materials.
Democracy has never promised good leaders. It promises only a way to replace leaders without bloodshed. The rest depends on what we require of those seeking office. As long as we demand only money and popularity, we will keep getting the rich and the famous, then sit bewildered, asking why our regions never seem to progress.
The ballot box is not blind. It merely reflects what we place before it.
First published in odiyaiwuu.com
Readers’ Responses