All notes

Land & Dignity

Racism in Indonesia’s Mass Media

IN INDONESIA, a chicken killed on a motorway in Java can become a national event. It is replayed on television, splashed across news websites, discussed at length on social media, even analysed as though the fate of the republic were at stake. Cameras arrive swiftly, microphones are offered with sympathy, and experts are called upon to speak. At the same time, in Papua, thousands of Indigenous Papuans are killed, driven from their land, left to live for years as displaced people and to die without a name. No breaking news. No special coverage. No national anguish. As though the tragedy were not a matter for the nation, but a minor disturbance in a corner of the map.

The contrast is too stark to be dismissed as coincidence. It reveals a hierarchy of value at work in Indonesia’s mass media, in which trivial events at the centre are deemed more important than humanitarian tragedies at the margins. Media outlets that proudly call themselves national fail to act nationally when it comes to Papua. The criticism must be stated plainly: this is not merely journalistic negligence, but structural racism operating with quiet efficiency through the selection of news and the production of silence.

The media always take refuge behind the sacred term ‘news value’. Proximity, impact and public interest are invoked as a mantra to justify editorial choices. But news value is not a law of nature handed down from the heavens. It is a construct shaped by perspective, interests and convenience. When the concept is used without reflection, it ceases to be a journalistic tool and becomes a moral shield for excluding tragedies deemed troublesome.

If a minor accident in Java is considered to have national significance, why not the killing of civilians in Papua? If political gossip at the centre of power can fill the front pages, why is the displacement of thousands of Papuans treated as a local issue of no urgency? The answer is not complicated, merely uncomfortable to admit. The national media have never truly regarded Papua as central to the Indonesian public interest. Papua is acknowledged on paper, but excluded from the media’s imagination.

When Papua finally appears in the news, it is almost always presented as a problem. Conflict is labelled a security disturbance. Peaceful action is called a threat to stability. Political aspirations are reduced to separatism. The language of the media works effectively to shift attention from human suffering to the interests of the state. Indigenous Papuans are rarely given space as people who think and speak for themselves. More often, they appear as numbers, background, or objects of policies they never chose.

In this pattern of reporting, death becomes banal. Violence becomes routine. Human suffering is reduced to cold statistics. The media see no need to ask why violence keeps recurring, who suffers most, or what becomes of the victims after the cameras leave. All that matters is stability and order. Human lives are treated as minor details that can be left out of the main narrative.

The national media like to boast of their courage in challenging power. They speak loudly on safe issues, bare their teeth at harmless targets and play the hero where there is no risk. Yet that courage suddenly fades when the subject is Papua. Everything becomes sensitive, complicated and fraught. Caution is elevated into the highest virtue, when caution that always excludes the same victims is merely a polite way of protecting oneself.

Silence is often disguised as neutrality. Yet silence is a conscious decision. When the media choose to remain silent in the face of repeated, systematic injustice, they are taking sides—not with the victims, but with comfort and the status quo. This silence is not the result of a lack of information. The information is there; the facts are available. All that is missing is the courage to bear the consequences.

Many reject the term media racism because they find no explicit slurs or hate speech. They forget that modern racism rarely shouts. It works through consistent, repeated neglect. Choosing not to report, not to investigate and not to make room for voices are political acts. When this neglect always falls upon the same race and the same region, it is not coincidence, but an entrenched system.

The mass media do not merely report events; they shape collective awareness. What is repeated is deemed important. What is continually ignored comes to seem trivial. Seldom present in national coverage, Papua eventually disappears from the nation’s imagination. That absence breeds ignorance, then apathy, then the justification of violence. The public is trained not to be shocked when Papuans die.

The media’s double standards are laid bare when their empathy is fully engaged by distant tragedies but dulled to the suffering of Papua. They can grieve for victims abroad, condemn human rights violations in other countries and weep over global tragedies. Yet that empathy dries up when it comes to Papua, as though the suffering there were too close to acknowledge, but too dangerous to defend.

This is not a call to hate Indonesia’s mass media. It is a direct indictment of their failure to meet their ethical responsibilities. If the media still wish to be called a pillar of democracy, Papua must no longer be sacrificed for editorial comfort. So long as a chicken killed on a motorway is considered more newsworthy than the thousands of Indigenous Papuans who have lost their lives and their futures, the problem is not a matter of journalistic technique, but a systemic moral failure.

History does not record only those who commit violence. It also records those who knew, but chose to remain silent. Indonesia’s mass media cannot go on hiding behind professionalism and caution. They must make an honest choice: remain comfortable in a racist silence, or stand on the side of humanity with all the risks that entails. In the face of injustice, there is no neutral position. Silence is not wisdom—it is taking sides.

First published in odiyaiwuu.com

Readers’ Responses

Be the first to respond